Skip to content

Concerns among new depositors about deposit safety - Commerzbank takeover sparking worry

Bank Takeover Implications: Examining the Short-term and Long-term Effects on City and Savings Accounts of Commerzbank if Uncredit Should Assume Control

Concerns among novice savers due to the deposit insurance uncertainty following Commerzbank's...
Concerns among novice savers due to the deposit insurance uncertainty following Commerzbank's takeover

Concerns among new depositors about deposit safety - Commerzbank takeover sparking worry

Commerzbank Takeover and Deposit Protection: What You Need to Know

In the event of a potential takeover of Commerzbank by Italian bank Unicredit, deposit protection for Commerzbank account holders would primarily continue under the German statutory deposit guarantee scheme. This scheme protects deposits up to €100,000 per customer, a rule that applies to banks operating in Germany and across the EU.

This protection is independent of the bank's ownership status, so it would carry over if ownership changed to Unicredit, provided the bank continues to operate under the German deposit protection framework or an equivalent scheme. However, the situation becomes more complex if Commerzbank operations were integrated into Unicredit’s Italian banking framework, as depositors would then be covered under the Italian deposit guarantee scheme instead of the German one.

Many banks, including Commerzbank, may participate in additional voluntary deposit insurance schemes beyond the statutory €100,000, potentially increasing coverage limits. However, whether this would continue post-takeover depends on Unicredit’s participation and the terms of integration.

It's important to note that the credit rating of the country of origin plays a crucial role in the security of deposits, especially for a smooth and timely compensation in case of a crisis. Germany, where Commerzbank is currently based, has a top rating of "AAA", while Italy, where Unicredit is headquartered, has a rating of "BBB".

The situation of Commerzbank's subsidiary, Comdirect, regarding deposit protection in case of a Commerzbank takeover is not specified in the text. Similarly, the text does not provide information about the potential implications of a Commerzbank takeover by Unicredit on the credit rating of the combined entity.

In the case of banks like the Spanish banking giant Santander Group, deposits with the German Santander AG are protected by German deposit protection, but deposits with subsidiaries like Suresse Direkt Bank and Openbank are protected by Spanish deposit protection.

Unicredit has a holding company model, which means that Commerzbank could continue to exist as a legally independent foreign subsidiary with its own brand identity in case of a takeover. However, there is no guarantee that this would be the case.

In conclusion, account holders at Commerzbank would remain entitled to deposit protection up to €100,000 under the applicable national scheme after a takeover by Unicredit, either through the German deposit guarantee system if Commerzbank remains a German-licensed entity or through the Italian deposit guarantee system if fully integrated into Unicredit’s Italian operations. This aligns with EU-wide deposit protection regulations intended to safeguard deposits across member states.

[1] Financial Times [2] Reuters [4] Bundesverband deutscher Banken

Read also:

Latest