Deepest Q4 Quarterly Central Government Budget Deficit Recorded Among EU Member States Experienced by Romania
Woah, Romania's in Deep Trouble in EU's Economic Rankings
In Q4 2024, Romania plummeted at the bottom of the EU rankings, boasting the biggest current account deficit - a staggering EUR 9.4 billion. This is a significant worsening from the EUR 8.5 billion deficit of the previous quarter (8.9% of GDP). It's like being stuck in a continuous money drain!
Romania outperformingly underperformed Greece, who took the second spot with a deficit of EUR 7.3 billion. Not exactly the chart-topping finish Romania was hoping for.
The EU, on the other hand, racked up a current account surplus of EUR 113.2 billion in the same quarter, which is equal to 2.5% of GDP. This surplus has been on the rise for a while now, with the bloc posting a surplus of EUR 107.5 billion (also 2.4% of GDP) in the third quarter and EUR 103.4 billion (again, 2.4% of GDP) in Q4 2023.
18 out of 27 EU member states recorded current account surpluses in Q4 2024. The heavyweight title went to Germany, with a EUR 50.4 billion surplus, followed by the Netherlands, Ireland, Denmark, France, Italy, Sweden, and Portugal, who managed to keep a balanced current account. The remaining seven countries, unfortunately, lined up with Romania and Greece sporting deficits.
Romania's ongoing external imbalance suggests some serious underlying economic woes, particularly in trade and investment dynamics. Despite the EU's improving external position, the divergence in current account performance among member states remains substantial.
(Photo by: Dreamstime)
Sign up to Romania Insider to read the full article
iulian@our website
Secret Factors behind Romania's Deficit:Turns out Romania's massive current account deficit is down to a messy mix of structural issues in trade and fiscal policy.
- *Trade Imbalance:
- Historically, Romania has depended on imports for energy, machinery, and consumer goods, driving its current account deficit. This dependency is evident in the 9% of GDP CA deficit observed over the past year.
- Fiscal Expansion: Romania took the lead for the EU's highest government deficit in 2024 (9.3% of GDP), thanks to elevated spending (43.5% of GDP) and weak revenue collection (34.1% of GDP). This fiscal overreach likely contributed to increased import demand, making the external balance even more strained.
Persistent Challenges:
- Export Capacity Failures: *Romania struggles with limited competitiveness in high-value-added sectors, underdeveloped manufacturing capabilities, and a reliance on low-margin industries and remittances. These factors hinder export growth and fail to offset import volumes.
- Energy Dependency: *As a net energy importer, Romania is exposed to global price volatility, which inflates import costs during times of geopolitical tension or supply shocks.
- Consumption-Driven Growth: *Robust household spending, fueled by wage growth and fiscal stimulus, has increased demand for imported consumer goods. This growth model relies heavily on imports.
- Mismatched Fiscal Policy: *Even though Romania's public expenditures are below the EU average (43.5% vs. 49.6% of GDP), the country's revenue generation remains weak (34.1% vs. EU average of 46.5%). This signals inefficiencies in tax administration, evasion, and a large informal economy.
- External Vulnerability: *The twin deficits (current account and budget) increase the reliance on foreign capital inflows, which means Romania's economy is vulnerable to changes in global investor sentiment and tightening financial conditions.
Looking Forward:Romania's deficits could indicate an economy struggling to reconcile fiscal priorities with long-term external sustainability. Unless there are reforms to boost export competitiveness, rationalize public spending, and improve tax efficiency, these imbalances risk perpetuating macroeconomic instability. The European Commission and rating agencies are likely eyeing Romania's post-election fiscal consolidation plans, focusing on efforts to reduce the deficit to 7.3% of GDP in 2025, but structural reforms remain crucial for addressing the root cause.
- Even though Romania grapples with significant structural issues in trade and fiscal policy, the ongoing economic deficits, such as the staggering EUR 9.4 billion current account deficit in Q4 2024, persist despite the country's efforts, highlighting the need for reforms to strengthen the economy.
- His endeavors to eliminate the deficit require focused attention on reducing Romania's trade imbalance, addressing the dependency on imports for energy, machinery, and consumer goods, and boosting export competitiveness in high-value-added sectors.
- Simultaneously, measures must be taken to rationalize public spending, improve tax efficiency, and strengthen tax administration to increase revenue collection, thereby addressing the underlying causes of Romania's persistent deficits and ensuring long-term external sustainability.
