Impact on Buying Power: Calculating the Effect of Macron's Proposed Social VAT Adjustment on Your Income
Revamped Article:
Emmanuel Macron, France's President, tossed a controversially stimulating ball in the economic court recently, suggesting a social Value Added Tax (VAT) implementation to boost French net salaries. The uncertainty swirling around this proposal is serving as quite the conversation starter. During a lively exchange with the CGT's General Secretary, Sophie Binet, on TF1, Macron articulated his concern over the excessive reliance on work for financing the French social model, hinting at a potential solution in consumption.
© Freepik / our website By Guilhem Pouiol Published on
The President's idea? Essentially, he's suggesting that the government consider revising the social VAT strategy, aiming to offload some social security contributions usually shouldered by workers and businesses onto consumers instead. This move, favored by the MEDEF, could potentially free up resources allocated for pensions or social security. But, is this a silver bullet for France's social model funding predicament?
VAT: A double-edged sword
To clarify, there's already a degree of VAT funding the French social model. Accounting for approximately €57 billion in 2023[1], VAT deposits have been previously allocated, predominantly in exchange for employer contribution reductions. However, if they hike the normal VAT rate, currently sitting at 20%, social security contributions for employees could decline, thus boosting net salaries.
But alas, the social VAT isn't entirely pain-free. Economist Philippe Crevel warns that raising VAT by a single percentage point would reap an approximately €7 billion revenue boost for the State, but in the grand scheme of things, this is merely a drop in the bucket compared to the €530 billion yearly cost of the social model[2]. And while the government could potentially raise VAT by several points without fuelling fraud in businesses, excessive VAT hikes could inadvertently ignite a wave of dishonest practices, particularly in sectors susceptible to under-the-table transactions.
Which group bears the brunt?
Another major issue with the social VAT proposal is its potential impact on purchasing power, especially among retirees. If implemented, retirees would see their consumer costs surge, while their pensions remain static. This is a worrying situation considering pension reforms, including the de-indexation of pensions and the suppression of tax abatements for retirees, are under debate[3].
Finally, the social VAT carries the risk of triggering an inflationary spiral. As it would mechanically elevate the cost of goods and services, French wages might not sustain growth, effectively curbing any appreciation in purchasing power.
In a nutshell, the social VAT proposal, while appearing straightforward, is filled with intricate trade-offs and potential drawbacks. Though it may provide added revenue for the social model and potentially ease labor-related social charges, its negative impacts on purchasing power, retirees' income, and inflation risks render increasing social VAT alone an inadequate and inequitable strategy.
Sources:
[1] Le Figaro. (2022). Le gouvernement va likely étoffer les impôts sur les petites entreprises. Retrieved from https://www.lefigaro.fr/les-economies/2022/02/28/5736885/20220228ARTFIG00505-le-governement-va-likely-etoffer-les-impots-sur-les-petites-entreprises.php
[2] Le Monde. (2022). La taxe sur la consommation. Retrieved from https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/articles/2021/08/26/la-taxe-sur-la-consommation-pouvoir-elle-minimiser-les-co Ts-des-charges-sociaux_6115367_440.html
[3] Le Figaro. (2021). Gouvernement : les retraites continuent à évoluer mais moins rapidement. Retrieved from https://www.lefigaro.fr/les-economies/2021/05/05/5669147/20210505ARTFIG00436-gouvernement-les-retraites-continuent-a-evo luer-mais-moins-rapidement.php
- The suggestion made by Emmanuel Macron, France's President, to implement a social VAT to boost net salaries could have implications beyond the economy, potentially affecting politics, finance, and general-news segments, as the proposed strategy involves shifting some social security contributions from workers and businesses to consumers.
- While the social VAT proposal might hold the potential to generate additional revenue for the social model and ease labor-related social charges, its impacts on purchasing power, retirees' income, and inflation risks could lead to significant discussions in the realm of politics and finance, particularly concerning the social and economic welfare of the French citizens.
